2026 College Football: Week 12 Takeaways
Whether due to injuries or unsatisfactory performance, numerous Power 4 teams changed QBs this week. Some made their moves before the games began, whereas others had to adapt on the fly. We also had an unusual week of OT games: three ranked squads lost in extra periods for the first time. Our primary conference of focus will be the Big Ten, as much of the consequential action took place there. The Big XII and Pac-12 also get a couple looks, with the former dodging a major upset and the latter not being so lucky. This CFP chase is becoming fascinating with all the chaos across the FBS. Come check out my week 12 takeaways!
(4) UCLA Loses Dieffenbach and Their Perfect Season with Him
Strength of schedule truthers have been sounding the alarm on the Bruins for weeks. I didn’t accept that argument. Yes, they don’t look as good as some teams ranked below them, but they play a Big Ten schedule. Regardless of how that schedule ended up, it was mostly formed years ago. Nobody knew how their specific opponents would play in 2026, and UCLA beat all 10 teams they faced through week 11. Therefore, until someone actually beat them, they deserved a high ranking. Well, a team did beat them, and it was the worst possible outcome for the Bruins. I don’t just mean that because of the final score or because it was Michigan.
For three quarters, this game was dreadful. Michigan made a QB change during the week, benching struggling freshman Tommy Carr and bringing back Bryce Underwood, who they already benched once. Underwood’s time on the bench did him little good. He was wildly inaccurate, completing just 11 of 24 passes for 127 yards and a TD. Underwood also lost a fumble and did next to nothing with his legs. RB Savion Hiter (26/104) accounted for pretty much all of the Wolverines’ production. Luckily for them, UCLA couldn’t score either. This was a 3-3 game through 3 quarters, and turnovers were the primary problem for the Bruins.
QB Ty Dieffenbach (19/30, 188 yards, INT), who has really done a commendable job in relief of the injured Nico Iamaleava, did not play well against Michigan’s strong defense. He threw a pick, and he fumbled 4 times, losing two. The second lost fumble set the Wolverines up at the 15 to start the 4th quarter, leading to their only TD. Dieffenbach did lead a 15-play, 77-yard drive to tie the score though, with a 6-yard jump pass by RB Anthony Woods sending us to OT. That’s when disaster struck. On the first play of OT, Dieffenbach ran for 7 yards but stayed down in pain. Trainers needed a stretcher and a cart to move him several minutes later.
Nico’s brother Madden Iamaleava came in and played poorly. He hesitated too much, throwing behind a receiver and failing to take advantage of a wide-open running lane. Both of his team’s drives ended up with FGs because they started at the 25, not because he did anything. To be fair, Iamaleava may not end up being bad. He simply wasn’t ready for this. Thanks to the Bruins’ great defense, Michigan also scored only 2 FGs through 2 OT periods. They couldn’t overcome the lack of offensive production though, and the Wolverines won 18-16 in 3OT when they converted a 2-point attempt (Iamaleava whiffed on UCLA’s).
Michigan is now bowl-eligible at 6-5, but they’re still 5-6 to me. They are also no closer to solving their QB problem. The bigger story here is certainly UCLA. We don’t yet know the extent of Dieffenbach’s injury, but it seemed serious. The loss itself gives the committee to drop the Bruins multiple spots in the rankings, and if you remember the 2023 FSU Seminoles, the committee is not above eliminating a team entirely for a QB injury. Suddenly, next week’s game against USC might be a must-win affair. Iamaleava will have to play a lot better for any of this to matter though. It’s a shame for such a Cinderella season to collapse like this.
(10) BYU Holds Off Spirited Kansas Rally in Week’s Second 3OT Game
One of the sticking points among the Big XII teams ranked in the top 25 is the idea that BYU is overrated. Their resume isn’t necessarily better than that of (12) Texas Tech, who has one fewer lost. BYU’s recent win over (6) Notre Dame is the big feather in their cap, and it seems to be carrying them far. Since that game, the Cougars haven’t been nearly as strong. They lost to UCF and Utah while winning a close game against Arizona State. Both losses came on the road, where BYU is not as good. We should’ve seen this week’s game at Kansas as a potential trap, and while BYU escaped the trap, it did some serious damage first.
For almost 3 full quarters, this game was a field goal fest for BYU. QB Bear Bachmeier (15/26, 173 yards; 18/58/2 rushing, FUM) did not have an inspiring day throwing the ball, but he ran it well. His team stalled in the red zone though, leading to 3 FGs as their first three scores. Kansas matched that, but 2 Isaiah Marshall (20/28, 186 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs; 18/90/1 rushing) interceptions in the third quarter allowed the Cougars to reach a stronger position, along with their lone TD of the game. BYU’s offensive engine was RB LJ Martin (25/127/1), who finally looks all the way back from his injury. But the Jayhawks fought back.
Marshall rebounded well from the picks, putting up 10 points in the 4th quarter to tie the game at 16. The tying TD involved a 4th-and-8 conversion, where Marshall fired a 24-yard strike to WR Cam Pickett (7/67/1). With a 56-yard drive though, BYU still should’ve won in regulation. Somehow, K Matthias Dunn badly shanked a 37-yard FG as time expired, sending the game to OT. Both offenses really came alive at that point, scoring TDs in two consecutive overtime periods. However, neither team made their 2-point conversion in 2OT, extending the game. Kansas failed their try in 3OT while BYU succeeded, escaping with a 31-29 win.
This was a heartbreaker for Kansas, who lost their 7th game of the year and won’t be going to a bowl (unless a 5-7 team is needed and they get picked). They’ve played much better football the past three weeks but lost two heartbreakers during that span. BYU should feel lucky to be 9-2. Talentwise, they’re better than the Jayhawks, but they let them hang around and nearly paid for it. I can see the committee leapfrogging (11) Wake Forest above the Cougars after the Demon Deacons’ latest blowout. That would put BYU on the edge of elimination because the 12th spot goes to a Group of 6 team. It’s safe to say that their margin for error is zero.
Big Ten’s Bad Day Continues as (8) Indiana, (14) Ohio State Also Fall
For a conference that has won the last three National Championships, the Big Ten finds itself in an uncomfortable position following week 12. Curt Cignetti, the coach of (8) Indiana, spent much of the week criticizing the CFP committee. While his points were valid, he probably wasn’t the best messenger. After the game his team just had, he might want to direct his future criticism to the mirror. Cignetti has handled his QB situation questionably. From keeping an injured Josh Hoover on the field too long to benching the formerly effective transfer for Grant Wilson, Cignetti made some curious choices, but they hadn’t cost the Hoosiers wins.
Washington had designs on changing that. Wilson (8/16, 119 yards, TD, rush TD) got the start again and began with a couple of great drives. First, he led a 1-play drive with a 74-yard TD to WR Charlie Becker (6/167/1), and two possessions later, he ran for a score. Indiana’s defense let Washington match those scores, something you can’t blame on Wilson. The rest of the half was less effective for the Indiana offense. They punted twice and turned the ball over on downs. After a missed FG to start the 3rd quarter (a recurring theme for K Nico Radicic), Cignetti had enough and turned back to Hoover. As if Wilson missed the kick himself.
Hoover (7/13, 121 yards, TD) had better passing efficiency, but he only led the Hoosiers to 10 second-half points. The defense allowed the Huskies to match that output yet again, and the game went to OT. After a Washington FG, Indiana lost in the most apropos way possible: a missed FG. This time, Paddy McAteer was the kicker. Washington’s late-season rebound is commendable, but this was an unacceptable result for Indiana. The defending champs’ CFP hopes are in serious jeopardy, and they’re uncertain to even have a chance to defend their Big Ten crown. That’s bad, but they didn’t even have the worst day among Big Ten teams.
If UCLA didn’t have the worst Saturday, then Ohio State did. Tuesday was fantastic for them: the committee jumped the Buckeyes (and (13) Oregon) over (15) Iowa despite playing in the same conference and having an extra loss. Suddenly, their seemingly-dead CFP dream was revived. All they needed to do this week was consolidate that vote of confidence by beating Nebraska. The Cornhuskers lost 4 straight conference games before rebounding last week against lowly Rutgers, with a few of those losses coming in heartbreaking fashion. Nobody thought that they’d give OSU, a team they’ve beaten once in their history, much trouble.
Interestingly, Nebraska is one of the best teams in the nation statistically. They’re just bad at one really critical aspect of football: closing out games and claiming victories. That’s how they’ve lost 31 straight games to AP-ranked teams. Ohio State scored first, but the Cornhuskers took over from there, rattling off 21 unanswered points. Those who have watched this team knew to wait for the other shoe to drop, and it did: the Buckeyes scored 14 straight points to tie the game. Nebraska seemed to be collapsing yet again, but in the 4th quarter, the difference between the teams’ QBs became apparent and ultimately proved to be the difference.
The Buckeyes’ Luke Fahey (16/27, 259 yards, 2 TDs, INT) had his best game yet, but he threw a crucial INT during the final period. His inexperience showed in that moment, reminding us that he’s still a freshman. Conversely, Nebraska’s Anthony Colandrea (19/28, 200 yards, 3 TDs; 11/63/1 rushing) used his experience to his advantage. He led his team to 10 points on two 4th-quarter drives, making OSU’s eventual TD answer irrelevant. Colandrea played a clean and simply fantastic game, using his legs to pick up yards and set up big passes. His legs ended the game, as he ran for the two first downs that sealed Nebraska’s win.
This was only the second time OSU has ever lost to Nebraska, and it feels fitting for this team. These Buckeyes aren’t the ones we’re accustomed to, no matter how much the committee wills it so with their ranking. Fahey has been a clear downgrade from injured starter Julian Sayin, but did we expect anything different? He played well enough to win this one. The bigger disappointment is the defense, which fell apart a few weeks ago and bears the blame for the Buckeyes’ recent losses. With 4 defeats on their record, their CFP chances should be gone for real this time. It’s a remarkable failure for an expensive roster and coaching staff.
(17) Boise State Collapses Against San Diego State; CFP Spot in Peril?
I didn’t expect to be writing about this game late into the night. Boise State didn’t score in the first quarter at home against San Diego State, but they took a 7-0 halftime lead and felt like the superior team. Surely, they’d go on one of their second-half runs and put the game to bed quickly. QB Maddux Madsen (23/35, 311 yards, TD, 2 INTs; 5/12/1 rushing) had two 2nd-quarter INTs, but SDSU was lifeless on offense, punting on five straight drives. Whatever the Aztecs did in the locker room at halftime worked though, as they never punted again. Their red zone efficiency wasn’t great, but they scored on all 5 second-half possessions.
Boise State’s offense also woke up, and they didn’t trail until the final seconds of this game. Actually, they led 20-13 with 3:48 to go and simply had to hold SDSU one more time. The Broncos nearly succeeded, forcing a 4th-and-2 at the BSU 46. Aztecs QB Stone Saunders (19/37, 227 yards, TD, INT; 4/41/1 rushing) had Broncos draped around him, but as he fell, he somehow flicked the ball to RB Javion Kinnard (13/86), who reached the first-down marker. That momentum carried SDSU further, as Saunders tossed a 39-yard bomb to WR Jaylon Hawkins (6/89/1). He ripped the ball away from the corner, who couldn’t believe he didn’t intercept the pass.
Stupidly, the Aztecs went for 2 instead of a PAT, and they predictably missed. Luckily for them, the Broncos wanted to be the dumber team on this day. After recovering an onside kick, Boise State ran twice for 2 yards. They then oddly chose to throw to the sideline on 3rd and 8, which stopped the clock. Worse still, they went on 4th and 3 at the SDSU 45, and Madsen took a sack. That made it way too easy for the Aztecs, who went 30 yards and kicked a game-winning FG as time expired. These teams will meet again in the Pac-12 championship game, as SDSU’s win clinched their spot and guaranteed Boise State a rematch.
The question is what this will do to Boise State’s CFP hopes. My assumption has been that the Broncos are the committee’s favorite Group of 6 team by a mile. No others are ranked after all. Their 9-1 record was nearly spotless, with a close loss to Oregon ( a committee favorite) their only blemish. This failure against SDSU is another story. I’m still not sure it matters. Possible G6 contenders such as Memphis lost. Maybe UTSA, New Mexico, or Liberty could have a chance now, but they seem far behind Boise State in the committee’s eyes. As long as the Broncos have no more slipups, I still think they’re going to get the #12 seed.
Weekly CFP Update and Analysis
As usual, the CFP committee confused me. I just complained about their SEC bias last week, and their response was apparently to double down. Nothing changed in the top 4, but (5) Texas leapt over (6) Notre Dame after the Longhorns’ tight win over LSU. Even as someone who considers the Fighting Irish overrated, nothing I saw from Texas (against a team that now has 5 losses) suggested they should move above a team that also won big. At the bottom, FOUR 4-loss SEC teams made the rankings: (21) South Carolina, (22) Oklahoma, (24) Florida, and (25) Ole Miss. Somehow, none of them were Missouri. The Rebels even lost last week.
Those SEC teams barging in squeezed the Group of 6 out as usual. While the AP and Coaches polls have Liberty in the top 25, the committee didn’t bother. Combine that with (17) Boise State’s 7-spot jump (the most of anyone), and their message is very clear: even with a second loss, they see the Broncos as the only Group of 6 team worth including. That’s extremely critical after the Broncos’ stunning loss this week. I’m curious to see if a second G6 team joins the rankings for no other reason than to show the fans and media who’s next in line. The Broncos can make that irrelevant by winning out, but there’s no guarantee that they will.
In the middle of the rankings, a trio of Big Ten teams caught my eye. As I mentioned earlier, (13) Oregon improved 3 spots, while (14) Ohio State jumped up 6. In the process, those 7-3 teams passed over 8-2 Iowa at #15. I’m sure this is a strength of schedule thing, as the Hawkeyes haven’t had the toughest road thus far. Still, I can’t help but think that there’s a bias against defense-first teams with questionable offense. We’ve seen it with (9) Tennessee, and it happens to Iowa every year. There’s no stigma against teams that are imbalanced toward offense, just defensive squads. Iowa has every right to feel disrespected by the committee.
Looking ahead, with the week 12 results in mind, every team in the top 7 seems pretty safe. (8) Indiana is in trouble now, and I think their loss brings (12) Texas Tech into the critical 11th spot. The only teams in waiting are Oregon and Iowa, as (16) Kentucky also went down. USC at #18 would be next in line, and that seems too far with just one week plus conference championships remaining. The best chance for any of those four Big Ten teams would be to steal a bid by winning the conference. Clearly, there’s a ton to play for in week 13, and I’m excited to see how it all shakes out after rivalry week concludes.
